Cookie Exchange Party Favor | 2024 Cookie Swap Party Favor | Annual Cookie Exchange Ornament Prize | Cookie Exchange Favor


Shipping to United States: Free

Let’s get ready for the best holiday Christmas cookie exchange! This is our original 3.5 inch maple wood round ornament engraved with “1st Annual Cookie Exchange / Baked with love in 2024” (You choose 1st, 2nd, etc. - Add this to the personalization field.)

Choose the “Baked with love in 2024” as party favors for all guests or bundle with our 6 cookie prize winner ornaments. Add our printed Ballot Cards to help with your party planning (link below.)

Prize Ornaments included in bundle:

Prettiest Cookie
Most Festive
Best Tasting
Most Unique
Prettiest packaging
Best Overall

Printed (Mailed to you) Ballot Cards in 4x6 inch size card-stock found here:

Printable Voting Ballot 8x10 sheet found here:

Ornaments are made in Londonderry, NH. Follow our shop at the links below to see our newest creations!

Add our shop as Favorite ❤️ Etsy shop:

Instagram: @homesweetsigns


Shipping from United States

Processing time

1 week

Estimated shipping times

  • North America : 13 - 14 business days

I'll do my best to meet these shipping estimates, but can't guarantee them. Actual delivery time will depend on the shipping method you choose.

Customs and import taxes

Buyers are responsible for any customs and import taxes that may apply. I'm not responsible for delays due to customs.

Payment Options

Secure options
  • Accepts Etsy gift cards

Returns & Exchanges

I gladly accept returns, exchanges, and cancellations

Just contact me within: 7 days of delivery

Ship items back to me within: 21 days of delivery

  • Custom or personalized orders
  • Digital downloads
  • Items on sale
  • Conditions of return

    Buyers are responsible for return shipping costs. If the item is not returned in its original condition, the buyer is responsible for any loss in value.

    Questions about your order?

    Please contact me if you have any problems with your order.

    Privacy policy

    We love our custom orders! They provide inspiration for other shoppers and design samples are often shared through social media sites such as facebook and Instagram. For signs with dates, we will wait to post until after the date has passed. Signs with a full street address will not be shared.

    Realtors - we love sharing your SOLD BY signs on social media, tag us as well as you use them.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Custom and personalized orders

    Yes! Send us a message! We gladly create designs just for you!

    Gift wrapping and packaging

    We do! Send us a note so we can add a reminder to wrap your item!

    My item was mailed to the wrong address

    While this does not happen often, it is very important to check your current address saved on your account. We are happy to adjust the address before shipping but cannot be responsible for the shipping fees to resend package once returned back for insufficient address, wrong address, unable to deliver, forwarding expired, etc. We will reach out to the buyer if a package is returned to review options to resend.

    Is it possible to rush the order?

    We have a “rush order” which subtracts 5 days from the estimated shipping date available. Please include the listing below within the same order. Once the order is received you will receive a confirmation email with the shipping date adjustment. The rush order fee is per item and cannot be used for an entire cart. Please let us know if you have any questions!

    Overall great product and extremely gracious and helpful in getting it shipped just in time for our party! Highly recommend will defiantly look forward to next years

    Just what I wanted. Thank you!

    These were PERFECT! The seller worked with us to design exactly what we wanted and the winners of our cookie swap loved them!

    Came back a 2nd year to buy these! I love them for my cookie party! Everyone else loved them as well.

    Design sent within 24 hours, received within a week of ordering. Just what I needed for a cookie exchange. Packaging and presentation is great!

    Legal imprint